The Best Boat Storage in Shelter Island, New York
Top 3 boat storage facilities in Shelter Island, New York. Rated 4.4/5 stars based on our comprehensive security evaluation system.
Top Boat Storage Facilities
Ranked by our comprehensive security evaluation system
Shelter Island Yacht Club
Shelter Island Yacht Club
Shelter Island Yacht Club is a premier full-service marina and boat storage facility located directly on Dering Harbor. Established in 1999, this facility offers comprehensive boat storage solutions including both wet slips and dry storage options. The marina features state-of-the-art security with 24/7 monitoring, professional dock staff, and excellent maintenance services. With deep-water access and protected harbor location, it provides ideal conditions for boat storage. The facility is known for its professional management, clean facilities, and exceptional customer service, serving both members and transient boaters in the Shelter Island area.
Storage Services:
Sag Harbor Marina
Sag Harbor Marina
Located just a short distance from Shelter Island across the bay, Sag Harbor Marina has been serving the boating community since 2009. This full-service marina offers advanced dry stack storage with a 35-ton lift capacity, accommodating vessels up to 45 feet. The facility features comprehensive security systems including gated access, surveillance cameras, and professional staff. Services include complete marine repairs, winterization, detailing, and seasonal storage. Their convenient location makes them a popular choice for Shelter Island boat owners seeking professional storage with easy access to both Peconic and Gardiners Bays.
Storage Services:
Mitchell Park Marina
Mitchell Park Marina
Mitchell Park Marina in Greenport serves as a key boat storage facility for the Shelter Island area, located just across the bay with easy access. Established in 2012, this modern marina offers both wet slips and secure dry storage options with advanced security systems including monitored access and surveillance. The facility provides comprehensive boat services including seasonal storage, maintenance, and winterization. Their professional staff and well-maintained facilities have earned them strong customer satisfaction ratings. The marina's strategic location in Greenport makes it convenient for Shelter Island residents while offering full-service amenities and protected harbor conditions.
Storage Services:
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about boat storage in Shelter Island, New York
What are the typical costs for boat storage on Shelter Island, NY, and what factors influence pricing?
On Shelter Island, boat storage costs vary significantly based on the type of storage and boat size. Wet slips or moorings in marinas like Shelter Island Yacht Club or Dering Harbor can range from $100 to $300+ per foot annually for seasonal dockside storage. Dry rack storage at facilities such as Coecles Harbor Marina typically costs $50-$150 per foot for the season. Winter storage on land (indoor heated, indoor unheated, or outdoor) generally runs $75-$250 per foot for the winter months. Key factors influencing price include location (protected harbors like Coecles or Dering command premiums), amenities (electric, water, security), covered vs. uncovered options, and the length of your vessel. Due to high demand and limited space, especially for larger boats over 30 feet, it's advisable to book well in advance, often by early spring for summer or early fall for winter.
How does the climate on Shelter Island affect my choice between indoor and outdoor winter boat storage?
Shelter Island's maritime climate features cold, damp winters with occasional freezing temperatures, nor'easters, and salt spray, making protection crucial. Indoor heated storage, available at select facilities, is ideal for preventing freeze damage to engines and systems, controlling humidity to inhibit mold, and allowing for off-season maintenance. Indoor unheated storage still offers protection from snow/ice load and UV degradation. Outdoor storage on land is common but requires a robust, professionally fitted cover and proper winterization to withstand precipitation and wind. Given the island's exposure to coastal storms, a secure, well-drained outdoor lot is essential. Many owners opt for indoor storage for higher-value boats or those with sensitive components, while trailered smaller boats may use outdoor storage with careful preparation.
Are there specific regulations or permits required for storing a boat on Shelter Island, NY?
Yes, Shelter Island has local regulations to consider. For long-term storage on private property, you may need a permit from the Town Building Department if the boat exceeds certain size thresholds or is considered a structure. Storing a boat in a designated wetland or dune area is heavily restricted. For marina or commercial storage, the facility handles permits, but you must ensure your boat is properly registered and insured. During the off-season, some marinas have rules about shrink-wrapping and waste disposal. Additionally, if using a mooring in town waters (like in West Neck Harbor or Coecles Harbor), a permit from the Town Clerk's office is required, and there are often waiting lists. Always check with your storage provider and the Town of Shelter Island for the latest requirements.
What types of boat storage are most available on Shelter Island, and how does seasonality impact availability?
Shelter Island primarily offers wet slips/moorings for seasonal in-water use and dry storage (rack, indoor, outdoor) for offseason. Due to its popularity as a summer boating destination, seasonal wet slips from May to October are in very high demand and often booked a year in advance. Dry rack storage for smaller powerboats and sailboats is available but limited. For winter (November-April), outdoor yard storage is more readily available, but premium indoor space is scarce and reserved early. Many facilities are marina-based and cater to seasonal clients, so year-round storage options are limited. The island's small size and strict zoning mean new storage facilities are rare, leading to competitive availability. It's critical to secure storage by early fall for winter and by winter for the following summer season.
What security measures and amenities should I expect from boat storage facilities on Shelter Island?
Given Shelter Island's relative seclusion and high-value boats, security is a priority. Reputable facilities typically offer gated access with key codes or cards, 24/7 video surveillance, and well-lit premises. On-site staff or live-in managers are common during the season. Amenities vary: full-service marinas like Shelter Island Marina provide power and water at slips, pump-out stations, fuel docks, and repair services. Winter storage yards often include haul-out/launch services, pressure washing, and winterization support. However, due to the island's rustic nature, some smaller yards may have fewer amenities. Look for facilities with storm-ready setups, as Shelter Island can be vulnerable to severe weather. Always inquire about insurance requirements and whether the facility has a clear protocol for hurricane preparations.
Nearby Cities
Explore boat storage facilities in cities near Shelter Island
About Shelter Island, New York
Shelter Island boat owners deserve secure, convenient storage when choosing boat storage facilities. Our featured facilities specialize in boat storage, RV storage, and marina services with personalized storage solutions in New York.
Local Expertise
Facilities familiar with Shelter Island community and local boat storage needs.
Trusted Security
Licensed and secure facilities with proven safety records in Shelter Island.
Personalized Service
Customized storage solutions and dedicated support for boat owners.